Case files stacked on an office desk

Two joint and several tax liability claims annulled on limitation grounds

Before the Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal, we obtained the annulment of two joint and several liability decisions issued by the Spanish Tax Agency under article 42.2.a) of the General Tax Law, for approximately 1.3 million and 320,000 euros, on the grounds that the Administration’s right to declare that liability was time-barred. Both decisions are final.

2 min readPrivate wealth

The TEAC annuls liability claims of more than 1.6 million euros, confirming that action against the principal debtor does not interrupt limitation against a party not yet declared liable.

The starting point

In two separate proceedings, the Spanish Tax Agency declared our clients jointly and severally liable for the tax debts of third-party companies, on the grounds that they had helped to conceal or transfer assets of the debtor company to prevent the Administration from acting (article 42.2.a) of the General Tax Law). The liability amounted to approximately 1.3 million euros in the first case and around 320,000 euros in the second.

In both cases, the facts on which the claim was based went back several years before the liability proceedings began, and the debtor companies had been declared insolvent during that period.

The challenge

A joint and several liability claim transfers someone else’s tax debt to the assets of the party declared liable. The Administration argued that the period for declaring liability had been interrupted by the collection actions taken against the debtor company and by its declaration of insolvency.

The defence therefore had to establish that the right to declare liability is a power distinct from the right to demand payment of the principal debt, with its own limitation period and its own grounds for interruption, and to maintain that position through the various instances.

Our approach

We took on our clients’ defence from the start of the liability proceedings, submitting arguments at the administrative stage, and then in the claims before the Regional Economic-Administrative Tribunal of Catalonia. When these were dismissed, we lodged an appeal before the Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal.

Our defence was built around three arguments:

  • Start of the limitation period: the period for declaring liability starts on the date of the facts on which it is based, not when the principal debt is determined.
  • No interruption: collection actions against the principal debtor, taken without formal notice to the party held liable, do not interrupt limitation against someone who has not yet been declared liable.
  • Insolvency of the principal debtor: the declaration of insolvency of the debtor company neither interrupts nor suspends the period for declaring joint and several liability.

The outcome

In 2025 the Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal upheld both appeals, annulled the decisions of the regional tribunal and the liability decisions, and declared that the Administration’s right to declare our clients jointly and severally liable was time-barred. As a result, claims totalling more than 1.6 million euros were set aside. The Administration did not appeal the decisions, which are final.

In line with Supreme Court case law, the TEAC confirmed that declaring liability and demanding payment from a party already declared liable are distinct powers, each with its own time limits and grounds for interruption. Neither the collection actions against the principal debtor nor its declaration of insolvency therefore interrupt limitation against a party who has not yet been declared liable.

Do you have a similar case?

We will reply as soon as possible.

Contact us now

Choose which cookies you allow. Technical cookies cannot be switched off because the website needs them in order to work. You can change your decision at any time from the "Cookie settings" link in the footer. Cookie policy

  • Technical

    Always active

    They store your cookie choice and allow the website to work, for example to send forms. They do not collect browsing data.