Façade of the Supreme Court in Madrid

Cassation appeal before the Supreme Court on how COVID aid is calculated for self-employed people with several activities

We prepared and filed a cassation appeal, admitted by the Supreme Court, so that it sets case law on how direct COVID aid must be calculated when the beneficiary carries on activities taxed under both the direct assessment and the objective (flat-rate) assessment methods.

4 min readSMEs

The Supreme Court finds cassation interest in a question with no previous case law and general reach

The starting point

Our client, a self-employed businessman, has for decades run a graphic arts business taxed for personal income tax (IRPF) under the direct assessment method. He also earns occasional, small income from a farming activity taxed under the objective (flat-rate) assessment method.

After his turnover fell during the pandemic, he applied for the extraordinary business solvency aid provided for in Royal Decree-law 5/2021 solely for his graphic arts business, which was one of the eligible sectors. The farming activity was not, and he did not apply for any aid for it.

The regional administration granted the aid but calculated it with the cap set for those taxed under the objective assessment method, far lower than the one that applied to the activity in the application. To do so it applied a rule giving precedence to the objective assessment method, contained in the ministerial order that set out the criteria for the aid and reproduced in the regional rules. After the administrative appeal was dismissed, the High Court of Justice of Catalonia upheld that approach.

The challenge

Royal Decree-law 5/2021 sets two ways of calculating the aid, depending on whether the eligible activity is taxed under the objective or the direct assessment method, but it contains no rule for a beneficiary who carries on activities under both. The precedence rule came from regulations, not from the law.

The underlying question was therefore whether a regulation can impose that precedence when the aid is requested only for an activity under direct assessment that meets the legal requirements on its own, or whether doing so alters the scheme set by a rule with the force of law.

In addition, an administrative cassation appeal requires showing an objective cassation interest for the formation of case law. Disagreeing with the judgment is not enough: the question must matter beyond the specific case.

Our approach

We handled the appeal from the analysis of the case to its filing before the Supreme Court:

  • Analysis of the facts: we reviewed the activity declared in the application, the tax regime of each activity and the facts the judgment itself held to be proven.
  • Viability of the appeal: we assessed whether there was a legal question with no previous case law and with general reach over a large number of recipients of this aid.
  • Procedural strategy: we built the appeal around the infringement of article 3.2 of Royal Decree-law 5/2021 and of the principle of the hierarchy of norms in article 9.3 of the Constitution, and justified the cassation interest under several of the grounds provided for in the Law on Administrative Jurisdiction.
  • Preparation and filing: we drafted the notice of preparation before the lower court and, once the appeal was admitted, the appeal brief before the Supreme Court.

The outcome

In July 2026, the First Section of the Administrative Chamber of the Supreme Court admitted the appeal. The admission order notes that there is no case law on the question and stresses that it raises an issue of interpretation with general reach, which goes beyond the specific case and may affect a large number of situations.

The Supreme Court set two questions of cassation interest: whether the autonomous communities may depart from the State’s interpretative criterion on how the aid is calculated when the applicant carries on two activities taxed under different regimes and, if not, whether the precedence of the objective assessment method can apply when the aid was requested only for an activity not subject to that regime.

In the appeal brief, filed in October 2026, we answered both in turn. First, that the autonomous communities must respect the State’s interpretative criterion, as this is an aid scheme applied uniformly throughout Spain. Second, that this criterion, read in line with the law and the principle of the hierarchy of norms, does not allow the precedence of the objective assessment method when the aid was requested only for a different eligible activity, taxed under direct assessment and meeting the legal requirements on its own.

The appeal is awaiting judgment. The Supreme Court’s decision will set case law on a question that matters to self-employed people and businesses that, like our client, combine activities subject to different tax methods.

Do you have a similar case?

We will reply as soon as possible.

Contact us now

Choose which cookies you allow. Technical cookies cannot be switched off because the website needs them in order to work. You can change your decision at any time from the "Cookie settings" link in the footer. Cookie policy

  • Technical

    Always active

    They store your cookie choice and allow the website to work, for example to send forms. They do not collect browsing data.