Agile due diligence without losing depth

In the mid-market, the timetable of a due diligence depends as much on coordination between specialisms as on the rigour of each review. How to organise a legal, tax, employment and financial review that reaches closing on time.

3 min read

When a deal slips, the cause is not always the depth of the review. It often lies in the different teams requesting the same documents separately, at different times and with different criteria. The buyer ends up with several versions of the same fact, and the seller, tired of answering the same question several times, stops prioritising the requests that really matter.

A single request list

The first decision that shortens timeframes is to merge the information request into a single document, ordered by priority for closing rather than by specialism. The seller provides the information only once, and the data room opens with a structure that anticipates the index of the report.

This requires the legal, tax, employment and financial teams to coordinate their requests before sending the first one, not after receiving the first answer. A single list, with an owner and a deadline for each item, avoids duplication and makes it possible to spot earlier which information does not exist and will require a specific representation in the agreement.

First, what could jeopardise the deal

Not all findings carry the same weight. It pays to distinguish as early as possible between what could make the deal fail (a material tax contingency, excessive dependence on a single customer, an expired licence the business depends on) and what is relevant but manageable with a standard clause. Reviewing first things first avoids reaching closing week with a surprise that should have been spotted at the start.

Risks quantified, not just listed

A useful due diligence report translates each finding into impact: estimated amount, probability and means of cover. An unquantified tax contingency is of no use in a negotiation; with an amount and a limitation period, it becomes a price adjustment, a retention of part of the price in an escrow account, a specific representation in the agreement or cover through a specific insurance policy for that contingency.

The same happens with employment and environmental findings, which often remain as a list of issues never translated into euros. A workforce with a high proportion of irregular fixed-term contracts, for example, is not just a compliance observation: it may mean their conversion into permanent contracts, severance payments and penalties, and it should be presented with an estimate of its cost.

In parallel, the financial due diligence analyses the quality and recurrence of EBITDA, net financial debt and the working capital required, which are the figures on which the price is set. Integrating it with the other reviews allows each contingency to be valued on the same numbers.

Materiality: where to set the bar

Setting a materiality threshold at the outset, below which a finding is not reported, saves time and keeps the report from filling up with minor issues that dilute the relevant ones. That threshold can also serve as a reference for negotiating the individual threshold (de minimis) and the aggregate threshold (basket) in the agreement, which determine the amount from which the buyer can claim.

The bridge to the sale and purchase agreement

Findings should be carried straight into the sale and purchase agreement (SPA): representations and warranties that cover exactly what was found, with time and monetary limits consistent with the risk, and an indemnity regime that does not fall short against tax and employment contingencies, whose limitation periods usually exceed those customary for corporate warranties.

That is why the representations and warranties should not be finalised from a standard template before the due diligence report is available. If they are only partially adjusted afterwards, the result is generic warranties that do not cover the specific risk identified, or indemnity periods shorter than the real exposure.

If you are preparing a sale and purchase transaction, our Corporate and M&A, Tax, Employment and Financial Consulting teams can coordinate the review from the first information request to signing, within a single multidisciplinary report.

Frequently asked questions

It depends on the size and complexity of the target company, the scope of the review and how quickly the seller provides the information. More than the volume of documentation, what usually sets the timetable is organisation: merging the requests of all the specialisms and setting a materiality threshold from day one are the measures that shorten timeframes the most.

A listed finding describes a risk without assigning it an economic value or a probability. A quantified one includes an estimated amount, a probability range and a specific way of covering it, such as a price adjustment, a retention of part of the price, a specific representation or a specific insurance policy. That is what allows it to be negotiated in the sale and purchase agreement on the basis of data rather than impressions.

It can be prioritised, but not cut without criteria. A review focused on the issues that could jeopardise the transaction, known as red flag due diligence, allows faster progress. Whatever is not reviewed in depth should be covered by appropriate representations and warranties in the agreement, so as not to take on unprotected risks.

Need advice on M&A?

Get in touch and we will reply as soon as possible.

Contact us

Choose which cookies you allow. Technical cookies cannot be switched off because the website needs them in order to work. You can change your decision at any time from the "Cookie settings" link in the footer. Cookie policy

  • Technical

    Always active

    They store your cookie choice and allow the website to work, for example to send forms. They do not collect browsing data.