In a disciplinary dismissal, proving the misconduct is not enough. The court also examines whether the company has complied with the formal requirements and the procedure, and a defect in any of them leads to the dismissal being ruled unfair, regardless of how serious the facts are.
The dismissal letter
The dismissal must be notified in writing, stating the facts behind it and the effective date. The facts must be described in enough detail for the employee to be able to defend themselves: what happened, when and in what circumstances. Generic wording, such as a "repeated breach of their obligations" without concrete facts or dates, is a frequent cause of dismissals being ruled unfair. Moreover, at trial the company may only rely on the facts set out in the letter.
The effective date must be stated precisely. Leaving it out or getting it wrong may be treated as a formal defect and creates uncertainty about how to count the twenty working days the employee has to challenge the dismissal.
It is also worth checking the applicable collective agreement, which may impose additional requirements, and the safeguards for certain employees: legal representatives of the workforce are entitled to an adversarial disciplinary file and, if the employee is a union member and the company knows it, the union delegates must be heard beforehand.
Hearing the employee beforehand
Since the judgment of the full Labour Chamber of the Spanish Supreme Court of 18 November 2024, the company must give the employee the opportunity to answer the charges before the dismissal is decided, applying Article 7 of ILO Convention 158. There is no specific statutory form or deadline, but the hearing must be genuine: the courts have found very short deadlines, or handing over the charges and the dismissal letter at the same time, to be insufficient. The advisable approach is to document it in writing and allow a reasonable period to submit a response. Failing to hold it leads to the dismissal being ruled unfair.
Limitation periods
Very serious misconduct, which is what can justify a dismissal, becomes time-barred sixty days after the company becomes aware of it and, in any case, six months after it was committed. Investigating is necessary, but once the facts are established it is best not to delay the decision: a dismissal communicated out of time will be ruled unfair, however serious the misconduct.
The evidence
Before drafting the letter, it is worth gathering evidence of the facts: internal reports, emails, witness statements or activity logs, depending on the case. It must be obtained within the legal limits on monitoring employee activity and data protection, because evidence obtained in breach of fundamental rights will not be admitted at trial. It is also useful to check for prior warnings or sanctions for similar conduct, which reinforce the proportionality of the measure.
Employees with special protection
The dismissal of pregnant employees, of those on birth or childcare leave, reduced working hours or leave of absence to care for family members, or of victims of gender-based or sexual violence, among other cases, will be null and void unless it is ruled fair. Nullity requires the employee to be reinstated and paid the wages lost, so checking these circumstances is a mandatory first step.
Acknowledging the dismissal as unfair: when it can make sense
If, having weighed the evidence, the risk of the dismissal being ruled unfair is high, the company can acknowledge it as unfair and pay the statutory severance, avoiding the cost and uncertainty of proceedings. For the severance to be exempt from personal income tax within the legal limits, the unfairness must be acknowledged at the conciliation hearing before the competent administrative service or in court; acknowledging it in the letter itself is not enough. It is a decision best taken with the employment and tax figures worked out in advance.
If your company is considering a disciplinary dismissal, reviewing the procedure, the letter and the evidence before communicating it significantly reduces the risk of it being ruled unfair. Our Employment team, working with our Tax team, can analyse the case before the decision is taken.