The family protocol is signed in peacetime

Many family protocols are drawn up once the conflict is already on the table. We look at what the document should cover, how to make it effective and why the best time to negotiate it is while it is not yet needed.

3 min read

A family protocol is not just another corporate document. It is the framework that governs how ownership, management and family coexist within the same company, and its usefulness depends to a large extent on when it is negotiated.

What it should cover

An effective protocol addresses, at minimum, four areas: the conditions under which family members can join the board of directors and hold jobs and management roles; the regime for the transfer of shares, with pre-emption rights and valuation rules agreed in advance; dividend policy; and the bodies and mechanisms for resolving disagreements before they reach the courts; as well as reinforced quorums on the board or at the general meeting of shareholders for certain decisions.

Of all of them, valuation is the one that prevents the most conflicts. Fixing the method before there is a buyer or an inheritance on the table removes the most common dispute between branches of the family.

How to make it effective

The protocol is, in essence, a shareholders' agreement: it binds those who sign it, but it cannot be enforced against the company or third parties unless its clauses are carried over into the articles of association. Even so, it is advisable to carry its agreements over to the articles as far as possible, within the limits of the Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital). The rules also allow the protocol to be made public at the Commercial Registry.

Family council and board of directors

They are different bodies and should not be confused. The board of directors runs the company and acts in its interest, which is common to all shareholders, family or not. The family council is the forum where the family deals with its relationship with the business (expectations, career paths for the next generation or dividend policy) without stepping into day-to-day management.

Keeping the two spaces separate prevents family discussions from spilling over into the board, and prevents management decisions that need speed from being delayed by a family conversation that is not theirs to have.

Why timing matters as much as content

Negotiated calmly, the protocol is an exercise in foresight in which everyone gives ground in the abstract. Negotiated with a conflict already open, every clause is read as a position of strength and agreement becomes very difficult.

This is especially true of valuation: when a shareholder wants out or there is an inheritance pending, any method is seen as favouring one side. Agreed years earlier, with no specific case in mind, the same method is accepted naturally.

Fit with the corporate and tax structure

The protocol works best alongside a matching structure. A holding company can organise the governance of the group and channel dividends from subsidiaries under the exemption in Article 21 of the Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act (Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades), which since 2021 applies to 95% of the income.

But in a generational handover, what usually matters most is access to the family business exemption from Wealth Tax and the reductions in Inheritance and Gift Tax. Their requirements (among others, minimum shareholding percentages, performing management functions and carrying on an economic activity) must be met within the chosen structure, and a poorly designed holding company can cause them to be lost. In addition, Inheritance and Gift Tax rules vary from one autonomous community to another.

Protocol, marriage settlement and will

The protocol does not replace a will or a marriage settlement (capitulaciones matrimoniales): they govern different matters, but must be consistent with each other. A protocol that reserves the shares for descendants who work in the business loses its point if the will splits them equally among all the children. In turn, the protocol must respect the forced heirship rights set by the applicable civil law, which in Catalonia, for example, also allows succession agreements as a planning tool. Reviewing the three documents together is what prevents contradictions.

Designing the protocol in good time and in coordination with the company's corporate, tax and estate structure is one of the areas where acting early makes the biggest difference. Our team supports the family throughout the process, from the initial assessment to signing.

Frequently asked questions

It is not mandatory, but the rules allow it to be made public at the Commercial Registry, either by recording its existence or by filing it together with the annual accounts. In addition, clauses that affect the company, such as those on the transfer of shares, must be incorporated into the articles of association to be enforceable against the company and third parties, in which case they are registered as part of the articles.

It is still worth it, but the process is different. In that context it helps to rely on mediation and move forward through partial agreements that reduce the tension, rather than trying to close a complete document in one go that each side would read as a position of strength.

There is no fixed schedule, although it is common for the protocol itself to provide for periodic reviews. In any case, it is worth revisiting when the facts that underpin it change, such as a new generation joining the business or a significant corporate transaction, or when regulatory, tax or civil law changes affect the succession of the company.

Need advice on Family business?

Get in touch and we will reply as soon as possible.

Contact us

Choose which cookies you allow. Technical cookies cannot be switched off because the website needs them in order to work. You can change your decision at any time from the "Cookie settings" link in the footer. Cookie policy

  • Technical

    Always active

    They store your cookie choice and allow the website to work, for example to send forms. They do not collect browsing data.