The notice opening a tax inspection is not a mere formality. It defines the tax years and the tax items to be reviewed and, with them, the ground on which the procedure will unfold. How the first few days are handled (what is submitted, by whom and under what criteria) shapes the room for defence available months later.
Read the scope before you respond
Before submitting any documents, it is worth checking which tax years and items are under review, whether the scope is general or partial and whether any of the years cited might be time-barred. Bear in mind that the Spanish Tax Agency can review tax losses and pending deductions for 10 years, even if they arose in time-barred years. The maximum length of the procedure should also be kept in mind: 18 months as a general rule, and 27 in certain cases.
The scope can only be extended through a reasoned decision, but information provided voluntarily on years or items not included may serve as the basis for that extension or for new proceedings. That is why it pays to stick to what is requested.
The notice also makes it possible to anticipate where the review will focus. If it expressly mentions related-party transactions, R&D&I deductions or the offsetting of tax losses, it is reasonable to prepare the supporting documentation from the outset: transfer pricing documentation, technical reports or the traceability of the losses pending offset.
The whole relationship with the inspector should be channelled through an identified point of contact. Scattered answers from different departments can create contradictions that are later reflected in the formal records and in the assessment.
In groups of companies or in businesses with several people in charge (finance, tax, legal), centralising communication is particularly important: partial information from different sources tends to lead to new questions and lengthens the procedure.
What to submit and how
The Inspection’s requests must be answered, and failing to do so may constitute an offence. But answering a request does not mean providing more than is asked for. It is advisable to keep the answer to what is requested and to the scope of the procedure, to ask for an extension when the volume of documentation justifies it and to present it in an orderly way, so that the thread of each transaction can be followed without the inspector having to rebuild it from scattered files.
Assessments in agreement, in disagreement and by settlement
The outcome is recorded in an assessment, and the type chosen has different consequences. In an assessment signed in agreement, the taxpayer accepts the proposed adjustment and the penalty is reduced by 30%, with a further 40% reduction if it is paid within the voluntary period without appeal. In an assessment signed in disagreement, the dispute is maintained, with the possibility of making submissions and appealing, but without the 30% reduction; and, if an appeal is lodged, the 40% reduction does not apply either. The assessment by settlement, reserved for cases that require valuations or the specification of undefined legal concepts, reduces the penalty by 65%, requires the resulting amount to be deposited or secured and, through administrative channels, can only be challenged on grounds of absolute nullity.
The choice between them should not be made at the moment of signing: it requires having quantified beforehand the cost of each option, including the tax due, late-payment interest, the penalty and the real chances of success of an appeal.
Appeals and suspension
If an appeal is chosen, it is worth deciding in advance whether to request suspension of the debt and with what security, because a defective request can make the debt enforceable while the appeal is being decided. Penalties under appeal, on the other hand, are suspended automatically, without the need for security, until they become final through administrative channels.
Directors' liability
If the company does not pay the resulting debt, the Spanish Tax Agency can extend liability to its directors, de facto or de jure, in the cases provided for by law. That is why it is advisable to document from the outset the relevant decisions of the governing body and the measures taken to meet tax obligations, especially in groups and in companies under cash-flow pressure.
If your company has received a notice opening a tax inspection, it is worth reviewing the scope and preparing the response before the first contact with the inspector. Our Tax team supports the company throughout the procedure.